Sister Michael Ann Monaghan was born to teach

Sr. Michael Ann

(This article was written in 2013. Sister Michael Ann continues to volunteer in the afternoon in the Finance office at Maple Mount.)

Ursuline Sister Michael Ann Monaghan taught first grade for 25 years, a direction that may well have begun with her first teaching assignment from Ursuline Sister Mary Ophelia Raley.

“On my first day, Sister Mary Ophelia gave me a long pointer and told me to take the three first-graders to the reading charts and help them to read,” Sister Michael Ann said.

The part left out of this story is that Sister Michael Ann was the fourth first-grader in the class at St. Joseph School in Central City, Ky. “I thought I was really special, I was already a teacher,” she said.

In the fifth grade, she met Ursuline Sister Mary Edward Pope. “She never talked to me about a vocation, but she was the kind of teacher I wanted to be,” Sister Michael Ann said. “She always encouraged us to learn all we could. She made school fun for us. I can still see her teaching us about volleyball.”

Sister Michael Ann wanted to be a teacher, and after joining the Ursuline Sisters, she got her first chance in 1954 at Immaculate School in Owensboro, Ky. “It was stressful. I thought ‘I’ll never be able to teach these children to read.’ But I think they liked school as much as I did,” she said. “I loved every minute of it. I knew this is what I wanted to do.”

Starting children off right in their first year of school is important, Sister Michael Ann said. “I thought if they liked school the first year, they would probably like it the rest of their lives. Their fear of school dissipated when they met me,” she said. “If the teacher is there for them, they’ll be OK.”

During Sister Michael Ann’s third year at Immaculate, Sister Marietta Wethington began her first ministry teaching second grade. “She was an excellent teacher, and she helped me to learn to teach,” Sister Marietta said. “She also taught me how to live in community.”

All the parents at Immaculate respected Sister Michael Ann and all the children liked her, Sister Marietta said. “Half of Immaculate Parish can read today because of Michael Ann.”

Hearing the call

Barbara Nell Monaghan was the seventh child of 10, and the family lived on a 10-acre piece of land during the Depression. The family had a garden that the children worked in. “I think (my father) did that to keep us busy,” she said. Her father was a coal miner, in the days when Muhlenberg County was the top coal-producing county in the state.

In 1981, the Ursuline Sisters celebrated 25 years of serving in tiny San Fidel, N.M., first going there in 1956. Pictured here, from left, are Sisters Mary Paula Hundley, Robert Ann Wheatley, Marie Brenda Vowels, Michael Ann Monaghan, Charles Marie Coyle and Sara Marie Gomez.

“He began working in the mines when he was 13,” she said. “His father died early and he had to help his mother. He was a veteran of World War I. He was a cook in the Army and arrived in France just as the armistice was signed.”

He worked in the coal mines in Wyoming before meeting her mother in Terre Haute, Ind. They took a steamboat to Central City for a mining job. They were lean times during the Depression, so her mother made all the children’s clothes, was an excellent cook and a good manager of the family resources, Sister Michael Ann said.

The first Ursuline Sister who believed young Barbara Nell had a religious vocation was her seventh and eighth grade teacher, Sister Mary Denis Bumpus. “She tried to encourage my vocation by giving me jobs to do, to see what the sisters did.”

Throughout attending a public high school, the thought of entering the convent was often with Barbara Nell. “I used to take time on my way home to stop in church and visit the Blessed Sacrament,” she said. “That got me thinking about a religious vocation.”

When her older sister, Sister Renee, joined the Ursulines in 1948, “I thought, wow, I wish I had that courage,” she said.

“I didn’t want to enter until I was sure God was calling me,” Sister Michael Ann said. “I took a year of discernment. My father told us when we graduated from high school, we were on our own. I told him I wanted to get a job in Hammond, Ind., I had two sisters there.” In high school she took an aptitude test that told her she would make a good inspector. She got a job working at Inland Steel, inspecting large sheets of tin.

During the 25-year anniversary celebration at San Fidel, Sister Michael Ann visits with the Most Rev. Jerome Hastrich, the second bishop of the Diocese of Gallup, N.M. Bishop Hastrich died in 1995.

She made friends and took advantage of what Chicago had to offer just a half hour away, such as museums, dancing and live shows. She saw Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis on stage. Despite the adventure she had, she knew she wanted more.

“I had a desire to serve God’s people,” she said. “I thought I could do so better as a sister.”

She thought about taking her parents’ names, but those names were taken. “My father always talked about our guardian angel and how important that was in our life,” she said. “I had an uncle Mike I was fond of, and my oldest sister was Ann, so that’s how I chose Michael Ann.”

On a mission

After nine years at Immaculate and a year in Louisville, Sister Michael Ann was excited to be asked about moving to San Fidel, N.M., to teach at St. Joseph School.

“It was a culture shock. I was in the desert, in two Indian reservations,” she said. “I began to love New Mexico in 1964-66. I liked the culture, the climate and the beauty we were surrounded by. I felt like a real missionary out there. I left a little bit of heaven behind when I came back here.”

She was asked to come back to Owensboro in 1966 to monitor the student teachers in her classroom, which she did at Sts. Joseph and Paul School until 1972.

The many Ursuline Sisters who served in Farmington, N.M., gather in this 1991 photo. Back Row – Sisters Sheila Anne Smith, Michael Ann Monaghan, Sara Marie Gomez, Frances Louise Johnson, Mary Edgar Warren, Marie Montgomery and Elaine Burke; front Row – Sisters Margaret Ann Wathen, Lisa Marie Cecil, Charles Marie Coyle, Mary Evelyn Duvall, Marie Brenda Vowels and Mary Angela Matthews; kneeling – Sisters Cecilia Joseph Olinger and Robert Ann Wheatley

While she was there, she asked to pilot a language arts program on reading. She encouraged the first-graders to enter a story in a national contest through Random House. One of her students produced one of her favorite stories ever, called “My Old Cow.” This is how it went:

“Her don’t eat. Her don’t sleep. Her don’t feel good. Her get baby calf and her happy.” The story won first place in the national contest and he received a picture dictionary as a prize.

Though she enjoyed her time in Owensboro, she recalled Mother Joseph Marian Logsdon’s promise that she could go back to New Mexico one day. Over the next 30 years, she would serve six stints teaching in New Mexico, finishing with St. Francis of Assisi School in Gallup in 2001. During some of those years she served as both principal and teacher.

“I always enjoyed wherever I was sent,” she said. “Each place was different, each group of sisters was different.”

Sister Marie Montgomery served with Sister Michael Ann for 16 years in New Mexico and said she was an excellent teacher. While serving as principal and sixth grade teacher in Gallup one year, she had a student who didn’t want to work hard. Under Sister Michael Ann’s tutelage, he went on to be student of the year in high school, graduated from college and has done well in his work life, Sister Marie said.

Sister Michael Ann, left, visits with Sister Clarence Marie Luckett, center, and Sister Rose Marita O’Bryan during Community Days in July 2012.

“His mother told me she gave all the credit for his success to the time Sister Michael Ann spent with him,” Sister Marie said.

In 2001, Sister Michael Ann came back to Hammond, Ind., to stay with her sister who was ill. In 2003, she began as a receptionist at the Mount Saint Joseph Conference and Retreat Center, and helped in the community business office. “I copied daily deposits, sorted forms, did shredding at the end of the day,” she said. “I’ve always liked numbers, I like working in a business setting.”

In 2009, she returned to family ministry, staying with her sister Agnes in Central City until she died on Aug. 1, 2012. “She was a widow and had taken care of our parents until they died,” she said. She and her sisters felt an obligation to help her when she had Alzheimer’s disease, and each took a year doing so.

“I felt like I received more than I gave. It’s such a blessing to help the sick,” she said. She also lost her sister Kathleen on the same day, and those sisters were very close, she said.

“It’s as if one said, ‘Come on, let’s go.’”

Sister Michael Ann going through paperwork in the community business office in February 2013. She volunteers in the office in the afternoons.

Sister Michael Ann is happy to be back at the Mount among the sisters. In the fall off 2012, she was thrilled when she was asked to help in the business office again, which she does each afternoon.

In her free time she likes to read and keep up with the news, especially politics. She loves music.

“She is a quiet person, but she can tell the funniest stories you ever heard,” Sister Marietta said.

Sister Michael Ann said she truly feels blessed to be a sister. “It’s been a wonderful life, I couldn’t have chosen anything better.”


By Dan Heckel


  1. Patty Mills Reynolds

    It was such a thrill to open up my Facebook and see this article. Sister Michael Ann is my aunt and while she is a wonderful nun and teacher, she is also an absolutely wonderful aunt. Thank you for this post.

  2. Mary Rene' Boarman Titzer

    Sister Michael Ann has always been an inspiration to me. she is kind loving and giving to everyone. She is intelligent and very well informed on current events. She is not afraid to voice her thoughts, even to her younger brother. I love you Aunt Babs! Mary Rene’

  3. Sister Ruth Gehres

    Hi Sister Michael Ann, my classmate . . . I loved reading your story! I remember all the funny things that happened in the novitiate, and then your stories about teaching all through the years. Some of those were funny too. It’s been good growing through the years with you. It was good to be with you when I was home at Christmastime. Blessings always, and love, SRuth

  4. B. Jan (Mills) Gish

    I was named after Sister Michael Ann. She’s always been such an inspiration to me…a combination of serenity, kindness, determination, curiosity, passion for life, and an Irish sense of humor. Sending her love!

  5. Jimmy Mills

    Hi, Aunt Babs! It’s a very nice story although you could have bragged a little more if you had wanted to. Thanks for the book you sent me. I haven’t read it yet but I will soon.

    BTW, Sister Michael Ann is my aunt. She was also my wife’s first grade teacher at Immaculate in 1959.

  6. Judy Boarman

    Hi Aunt Babs!It was a very interested story I enjoyed reading it very much. Aunt Babs you have been an inspiration to the kids you have taught and to me. I love you. Judy

  7. Judy Boarman

    Hi Aunt Babs! This article was very interesting to read. You have been an inspiration to your kids you have taught and to me. I love you Judy

  8. Mary Jo Nault (Sweatt)

    What a nice profile of you. I enjoyed reading about your life of service.
    Sister Edward was a great influence in my life too. She taught Algebra at the Mt when I attended and she challenged me all the time.
    Have you anymore family in Central City? I only keep in touch with one relative there, Hugh Sweatt. He attended St Joseph school too.
    If I’m still kicking I plan to come to the Mt for my 65 Academy alum day. Can’t wait!
    Take care of yourself and pray a little prayer for me now and again.
    Mary Jo (ex Sister Karen I)

Comments are closed